Titanic: 100 Years: Final Thoughts

Titanic’s Lifeboats in New York Harbor

After leaving the site of the sinking of the Titanic, the Carpathia carried the 705 survivors to New York. They arrived on April 18, 1912. Immediately following their return, an inquiry was held in the United States.  The US Inquiry lasted from April 19 – May 25.  At the same time, a British Inquiry into the sinking was held from May 2 – July 3.  It was determined that the ship was traveling too quickly, ignored several important ice warnings, and was not carrying enough lifeboats for the passengers and crew.  White Star Line owner, Bruce Ismay, was criticized for being among the survivors of the sinking.  It was also determined that the Californian was in the area of the sinking, but the wireless operator had gone to bed after being told to “Shut-up” by the wireless operators on the Titanic.

The loss of life was 1,517.  The fact that the ship did not carry an adequate number of lifeboats for all on board was to blame. There are a number of other contributing factors including: weak steel, calm sea, lack of moon light, the loss of the lookouts’ binoculars, the water-tight bulkheads only extending to E-Deck, and the lack of lifeboats. The important thing to understand, however, with all these weaknesses, the ship met every safety standard of the day. The sinking of the Titanic led to the creation of the Ice Patrol and changes in passenger liner regulations.  The Titanic disaster is the greatest ever recorded in peace time and could have been prevented had the regulations for passenger liners been tougher.

Today, the Titanic is resting on the ocean floor, slowly decomposing. The site is a grave site and should be left alone. Dr. Robert Ballard has repeatedly presented his arguments for leaving the Titanic alone, and I could not agree more. It is a sacred site and should be left alone. RMS Titanic, Inc. has opened the Titanic to salvagers and I refuse to visit any of their sponsored events or exhibits. Leave the wreck alone and allow those who parished on that April night rest in peace.

Where Titanic Failed, American Vessel Stood Tall

By: Susan Gibbs

Originally published in the USA Today, April 13, 2012

As we approach the Titanic’s 100th anniversary on Sunday, the doomed luxury liner seems to be sailing across every television and computer screen. Amidst the rapt attention paid to a British ship’s tragic end, the most famous ocean liner that never sank still bears the proud name United States. Though sadly overlooked by most Americans, our nation’s flagship still serves as an enduring symbol of American postwar power, pride and innovation.

There are many measures of a vibrant society — the freedom it guarantees its citizens, its technological advancement and the opportunities it affords its people, to name just a few. An advanced society is also one that appreciates its own history. As the red, white and blue funnels of the SS United States fade in Philadelphia, this storied ship, once a metaphor for American strength and ingenuity, risks becoming a tragic symbol of our nation’s decline. We cannot allow that to happen.

While the Titanic carried more than 1,500 passengers to a watery grave on her first Atlantic crossing, the SS United States barreled across the ocean on her record-breaking maiden voyage averaging 35.59 knots— or more than 40 miles per hour. On that historic trip in 1952, America’s answer to Europe’s dominance of the seas sped through the water with such force that bow waves blasted the paint off her hull. She became the fastest ocean liner ever built using only two-thirds of her power and still holds the trans-Atlantic speed record for a passenger ship, nearly 60 years after her launch. The SS United States could go faster in reverse than the Titanic could travel forward.

Storied history

After a ticker tape parade up the Canyon of Heroes in New York honoring her crew, the “Big U” went on to serve for 17 mishap-free years, carrying more than a million passengers across the sea, including four U.S. presidents, business moguls, movie stars, military personnel and immigrants beginning new lives on our shores.

SS United States Returns from its Record Breaking Maiden Voyage

Built as part of a top-secret Pentagon project to create the safest and fastest ocean liner ever constructed, the 1,000-foot-liner is 100 feet longer than the Titanic. The size of the Chrysler Building, the SS United States served as both a luxury liner and Cold War weapon, capable of transporting 15,000 troops, 10,000 miles without refueling.

Like the Statue of Liberty, the Empire State Building and the Washington Monument, there is only one SS United States.
Thanks in part to lessons learned from the Titanic’s tragic demise, the SS United States was designed for safety. The ship’s dual engine rooms ensured that she could still make port even if one of them flooded. The ship’s aluminum superstructure eliminated the need for “expansion joints” — small seams in the steel superstructure that contributed to the Titanic’s breakup.

Major safety precautions

The “Big U” was completely fireproof. Her designer, my grandfather William Francis Gibbs, took this mandate to an extreme. He demanded that Theodore Steinway customize the ship’s baby grand pianos in aluminum. Mahogany pianos were permitted only after Steinway offered to douse one in gasoline and ignite it to illustrate its fire-retardant qualities. The wooden shuffleboard discs were replaced with plastic alternatives, and the conductor’s baton was rendered in aluminum. However, as one magazine noted wryly after the vessel’s debut, they had “devised no way of rendering the musicians incombustible.”

Rather than resting some two-and-a-half miles below the ocean’s surface off the coast of Newfoundland, the SS United States still floats at a Philadelphia pier. Decommissioned in 1969, she has passed through the hands of a number of owners over the decades. The non-profit SS United States Conservancy saved the ocean liner from certain scrapping last year by purchasing the vessel, thanks to a grant from a patriotic philanthropist named H. F. “Gerry” Lenfest.

This irreplaceable piece of American engineering is now poised to serve our nation and the world yet again. Partners and supporters from across the country are needed to help redevelop the vessel as a mixed use destination featuring a museum, educational programs and other uses in an urban waterfront setting. The ship’s more than 650,000 square feet of interior space offers unique opportunities to explore and celebrate everything from American technological innovation, engineering, and postwar history to sea-going travel and the Mad Men era.

In response to the Titanic’s sinking, the bishop of Winchester stated: “The Titanic, name and thing, will stand for a monument and warning to human presumption.” The SS United States also stands as a monument and also issues a warning. Today, the Big U quietly warns us that time, tide and complacency can threaten even our most awe-inspiring patriotic symbols.

The Titanic and the SS United States both embodied their nation’s loftiest aspirations. But only one of these legendary vessels can still be saved for future generations. Once the Titanic memorials, movies and television shows become a memory, we have a chance to save our own history.

Susan Gibbs is the executive director of the SS United States Conservancy and the granddaughter of William Francis Gibbs, the designer of the SS United States.

Titanic: 100 Years: Titanic Sinks

Newspapers quickly spread the news of the sinking

This post picks up the timeline of the sinking of the Titanic, one hundred years ago today (and early tomorrow, April 15).  Here is the timeline (in local time):

12:00 AM – Captain Edward J. Smith gives the orders to call for help over the raido

12:05 AM – Captain Smith order the lifeboats be prepared for the passengers, knowing full well there would not be enough for everyone aboard

12:25 AM – Lifeboats loading begins, women and children only

12:25 AMCarpathia responds to distress calls, but is 58 miles from the scene

12:45 AM – The first lifeboat is lowered from the ship

2:05 AM – The final lifeboat is lowered from the ship

2:17 AM – Last distress call is sent

2:20 AMTitanic splits between the third and fourth funnels and sinks

3:30 AMCarpathia‘s rockets are spotted by the survivors

Titnaic’s survivors reach the Carpathia

4:10 AM – First lifeboat reaches Carpathia

8:50 AMCarpathia leaves the area for New York City

Titanic: 100 Years: Titanic Hits an Iceberg

One hundred years ago today, the unsinkable Titanic struck an iceberg in the North Atlantic on its maiden voyage.  What happended over the next two and a half hours has been retold countless times. Here is a timeline of the evening (local time):

11:40 PM – Titanic strikes an iceberg at latitude 41-46N, longitude 50-14W

11:50 PM – Inspections show 14 feet of water in the forward sections of the ship

To be continued…

Super Car Era?

In the 1960s and 1970s, America was in what has become known as the Muscle Car Era. With cars like the Ford Mustang, Ford Thunderbird, Chevy Camaro, Chevy Chevelle, Dodge Charger, Dodge Challenger, AMC Javelin, Pontiac Firebird, and Pontiac GTO – it is not hard to see how that era received that distinction. Today, however, few true muscle cars remain. The Ford Mustang is the only of those to have been in continuous production since its debut, but the Dodge Challenger and Chevy Camero have returned. This leads one to question, what will we fondly remember as we look back to today?

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Photos of all the cars mentioned in this post are in the slideshow.

Will we remember Chevy’s Malibu or Ford’s Fusion? Will we remember the Toyota Prius or other hybrid models? Is this the era of the hybrid car? I hope not. I have no problem with hybrid cars. They are practical and are environmentally friendly, all qualities I look for in a car, but these are not the types of cars we remember. Few people hail the practical cars from history. What then will we remember? Super Cars.

Jay Leno said on BBC’s Top Gear that hybrid and electric cars will become the norm. This allows the muscle and super cars to continue to exist, however. So what are the cars of today that will be the classics of tomorrow? Here is the list (in no particular order):

-Ferrari 458 Italia

-Pagani Zonda

-Pagani Huayra

-McLaren MP4-12C

-Lamborghini Aventador

-SRT Viper

-Corvette ZR1

-Ford Mustang Shelby GT500

-Aston Martin DBS

-BMW M5

-Mercedes-Benz SLR McLaren

-Porsche 911 GT3 RS

-Koenigsegg CCXR

-Aston Martin One-77

-Bugatti Veyron

-Noble M600

-Audi R8

-Lexus LFA

-Nissan GT-R

And the list goes on and on…. These are all cars that have come out in the last decade. And there are still more to come including the Ferrari F12 Berlinetta and Acura NSX. So while auto manufactures scramble to build cars that achieve the best gas milage, they are still building cars like these. While some people complain, I think they are important. The automotive world would be dull if all we ever talked about was small displacement engines and MPG. We need the occasional impractical car with a massive V12. All the cars listed above have well over 500 horsepower and a few them actually achieve decent gas milage.

As our technology improves, so do our super cars. Compare any of these cars to the super cars a decade previous and you get the McLaren F1 and the Ferrari F40. Again, great cars, but they are part of a much smaller group. With all these options are super car owners still a part of an exclusive group? Of course, it still takes a fat wallet to buy any of these cars, and a continuous supply of money to keep them fueled. Nevertheless, they are all important because they are exciting, and they give us something more to talk about than MPG.

Titanic: 100 Years: Titanic Hits the Open Water

The final photo taken of the Titanic, leaving Ireland – never to see land again

Today, one hundred years ago, April 11, 1912, Titanic continued its maiden voyage.  After stopping in Cobh (Queenstown), Ireland at 11:30 AM (local time), the Titanic hit the open sea.  The Titanic experienced smooth sailing for the next several days.

Titanic: 100 Years: Maiden Voyage Begins

Titanic docked in Southampton

On this day, one hundred years ago, April 10, 1912, the Titanic sat in Southampton, England preparing for her maiden voyage.  Here is a timeline of the day (local time):

9:30-11:00 AM – Passengers arrive and board Titnaic

12:00 PMTitanic leaves Southampton, having a near collision leaving the harbor

6:30 PMTitanic arrives in Cherbourg, France to take on more passengers

SS United States Conservancy Announces Partnership and Inventory Initiative

A few weeks ago, the SS United States Redevelopment Project announced a partnership with New Canaan Advisors LLC. New Canaan has worked on large projects in the past including Grand Central Terminal in New York and the World Trade Center site. The expertise brought by this group is a welcome addition as the Redevelopment Project tries to determine what to do with the SS United States.

The same day, The SS United States Conservancy launched the first phases of their museum planning and inventory process. The inventory process is the most important at the moment because the Conservancy would like to rediscover the objects from the ship that were sold at auction in 1984. This is not an effort to recollect the items, but just to have an inventory of the SS United States‘ existing artwork, furnishings, and other artifacts. The Conservancy has created a survey for those who have these items. For a pdf version of the survey, please click here.  If you’d prefer to complete the survey online, click this link.

As always, I fully support the efforts of the SS United States Redevelopment Project and the SS United States Conservancy. These efforts are even more important as time is running out. The Conservancy only has fund to preserve the ship until August. Please donate to the Conservancy today. That being said, I would like to call on the Conservancy to be more open about its plans and finances. Those making donations deserve to know what is going on.

Keep up with the latest Conservancy news by visiting their website or by following them on Facebook and Twitter.

Ferdinand Alexander Porsche (1935-2012)

Today the automotive world lost an iconic designer. Ferdinand Alexander Porsche, grandson of Porsche and Volkswagen founder Ferdinand Porsche, is famous for designing the original 911 (above). Although I am not a big Porsche or 911 fan, I understand the importance of the 911 to the automotive world. The car debuted in 1963 and has been a global best seller ever since. Porche is often criticized for its lack of innovation with the 911 as it has had a similar form factor since 1963 and has always been rear engined. Nevertheless, it is has been an important car. Interestingly, the 911 was not his favorite design. That honor belongs to the 1964 Porsche 904 racer (below). The 904 is a beautiful car. Ferdinand Alexander Porsche was a great designer and he will be missed.

Titanic: 100 Years: Sea Trials

Titanic leaving for sea trials

Today, one hundred years ago, April 2, 1912, the Titanic underwent Sea Trials and arrived in Southampton, England on April 3 to prepare for the maiden voyage.  It was reported that sea trials were successful.